Wednesday, November 4, 2026

From Source to Shelf: Can Consumers Really Know Where Their Food Comes From?

 


From Source to Shelf: Can Consumers Really Know Where Their Food Comes From?

CAIR examines food traceability, bulk imports, local repackaging and the need for greater transparency and accountability throughout Trinidad and Tobago's food supply chain.

What is on our plates, and what do we really know about it?

When consumers purchase food from a supermarket, grocery or market, they reasonably expect that the product has met the necessary food safety requirements. They may examine the label, check the expiry date, read the ingredients and look for the name and address of the local distributor or manufacturer.

But how much does that information actually tell them about the food?

A package bearing a Trinidad and Tobago business address does not necessarily mean that the food originated here. Nor does local repackaging establish where the original agricultural commodity was grown, how it was cultivated, which chemicals were applied, or how it was handled before reaching our shores.

These are important distinctions.

Food safety does not begin when a product arrives at our ports, nor does it end when a local company places it in a new package. It begins at the source and must be maintained throughout production, processing, importation, storage, repackaging and distribution.

Consumers cannot make fully informed decisions about food safety when the information necessary to assess its origin, production and handling is incomplete or inaccessible.

For CAIR (Consumer Advocacy and Information Resource), this raises an important question: Are the traceability arrangements governing food entering and circulating within Trinidad and Tobago sufficiently comprehensive to protect consumers and support effective regulatory oversight?

The repackaging concern: When a local label tells only part of the story

Consider a company importing agricultural commodities in bulk from another country.

The shipment arrives, is stored, divided into smaller quantities, repackaged under a local brand and distributed to supermarkets and retailers.

The consumer purchases the product bearing a local label. The packaging may identify the local repackager or distributor, but does the consumer have access to the original country of production, the producer, the original batch identification and the relevant production and handling history?

This is where traceability becomes particularly important.

Repackaging is a legitimate commercial activity. However, it must not result in the loss of information that allows the finished product to be linked to its original source.

The original batch identity must remain traceable, even where the product is divided into smaller packages or transferred between businesses. Where different batches are combined, the records must identify the contributing batches and the resulting product lots.

Without this continuity, establishing the source of a food safety problem can become considerably more difficult.

A local address identifies a local business. It does not, by itself, establish the complete history of the food.

The journey does not end with repackaging

Traceability must extend beyond the importer and repackaging facility.

Food products may pass through several wholesalers, distributors, storage facilities and retailers before reaching consumers. Each transfer creates another opportunity for information to become fragmented or lost.

An effective traceability system must therefore account for:

  • The original producer, manufacturer or agricultural source.

  • The country and location of production.

  • The importer and relevant import documentation.

  • Inspection and verification undertaken before distribution.

  • Storage, handling and transportation.

  • Processing and repackaging activities.

  • Changes in batch or lot identification.

  • Every subsequent distributor or business receiving the product.

  • The final retail destination.

This is not simply a matter of keeping administrative records. It is fundamental to identifying potentially unsafe food, determining where it has been distributed and ensuring that affected products can be removed from circulation.

Traceability must follow the food, not merely the business that first imports it.

What about Good Agricultural Practices and Good Manufacturing Practices?

Consumers are often unaware of the conditions under which their food was produced and processed.

Good Agricultural Practices (GAP) address agricultural production, including responsible pesticide use, soil and water management, harvesting and hygienic handling.

Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) address the conditions and procedures used in food processing, manufacturing, packaging, storage and handling.

These practices contribute to food safety, but their existence on paper is not sufficient. Compliance must be verifiable.

For imported agricultural commodities, relevant information should include:

  • The country and location of cultivation.

  • The producer or agricultural supplier.

  • Applicable GAP compliance records or certification.

  • Pesticides, herbicides and other agricultural chemicals applied.

  • Relevant application dates and conditions.

  • Compliance with applicable pre-harvest intervals.

  • Processing, storage and transportation conditions.

  • Relevant GMP compliance records for processing and repackaging.

The issue of pesticide use deserves particular attention.

For example, an agricultural commodity imported from the Philippines may have been cultivated using glyphosate or another agricultural chemical. Its subsequent packaging and distribution in Trinidad and Tobago do not erase its production history.

The fact that a chemical was used does not automatically establish that the resulting food is unsafe. The nature and level of residues, the applicable maximum residue limits, exposure and relevant scientific assessments must all be considered.

However, consumers and regulators should not be left without the information needed to assess these matters.

CAIR believes that the relevant production and chemical-use information should be documented, verified and accessible. Consumers should also have meaningful access to information about the agricultural chemicals used, applicable residue standards and relevant testing or compliance findings.

What does the international experience tell us?

Trinidad and Tobago is not alone in having to manage complex food supply chains. Other jurisdictions have developed regulatory frameworks that place greater emphasis on traceability throughout the movement of food.

European Union

Article 18 of Regulation (EC) No. 178/2002 requires traceability of food, feed and relevant substances at all stages of production, processing and distribution.

Food businesses must be able to identify their suppliers and the businesses to which they have supplied their products. The information must be available to competent authorities.

This is commonly described as the one-step-back, one-step-forward approach.

The important principle is that traceability continues through the supply chain, rather than stopping at importation or initial processing.

United States

The US Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA), particularly Section 204, introduced additional traceability recordkeeping requirements for specified high-risk foods.

The FDA Food Traceability Rule requires covered businesses to maintain key data elements associated with critical tracking events, including receiving, shipping and transformation.

Importantly, transformation includes activities such as repackaging, commingling and relabelling for foods covered by the rule.

Businesses subject to the requirements must be able to provide relevant records to the FDA within 24 hours or within another reasonable time agreed with the agency.

The rule is intended to facilitate faster identification and removal of potentially contaminated products. Its enforcement date has been deferred to July 20, 2028.

These international examples demonstrate that traceability is increasingly treated as an essential food safety management tool, rather than simply a labelling exercise.

How does Trinidad and Tobago compare?

Trinidad and Tobago already has food labelling provisions under the Food and Drugs Act, Chap. 30:01, and the Food and Drugs Regulations.

Regulation 16 addresses information required on prepackaged food, including the manufacturer or preparer, country of preparation or origin in specified circumstances, ingredients, date marking and batch or lot identification.

Regulation 23 also addresses certain food sold from bulk and bulk-container labelling.

These requirements are relevant and should not be overlooked.

However, the existence of labelling requirements does not, on its own, establish that a comprehensive traceability system is operating effectively across every stage of the food supply chain.

The distinction is between identifying information on a package and maintaining verifiable records that connect the original agricultural source to the finished product, every subsequent repackaging or redistribution event, and its final destination.

The Government's own National Food Safety Policy 2018–2023 recognised the need for improvement. Its assessment identified legislative gaps relating to comprehensive traceability and defined food recall procedures. It also highlighted challenges involving fragmented legislation, enforcement capacity, food safety surveillance and coordination among responsible agencies.

The policy called for comprehensive traceability and recall systems, strengthened laboratory capacity and improved coordination.

The critical question now is what has been implemented since that policy period, what remains outstanding and whether existing arrangements are being consistently enforced.

CAIR believes this warrants a transparent assessment.

When food safety fails, can affected products be traced and recalled?

Traceability is particularly important when a food safety incident occurs.

Suppose a shipment of agricultural commodities is found to contain pesticide residues above the applicable maximum residue limit, or an imported food is subsequently identified as contaminated.

If the original shipment was divided, repackaged under different labels and distributed through several wholesalers, authorities must be able to identify all affected batches and determine where those products went.

Where original batch information is not preserved, or redistribution records are incomplete, this process becomes more difficult.

The consequences can include:

  • Delays in identifying affected products.

  • Difficulty determining which retailers received them.

  • Incomplete or ineffective recalls.

  • Continued exposure while investigations are underway.

  • Unnecessary withdrawal of unaffected products where the affected batches cannot be isolated.

  • Difficulty establishing accountability among businesses involved in the supply chain.

An effective traceability system supports targeted recalls, faster investigations and better communication with consumers.

A recall should not depend on reconstructing a product's journey after a safety problem has already occurred.

What CAIR is calling for

CAIR is calling on the Government of Trinidad and Tobago and the relevant regulatory authorities to strengthen food traceability requirements and ensure their consistent implementation and enforcement.

We recommend a comprehensive framework that addresses the following:

1. Mandatory end-to-end traceability

Imported food should remain traceable from its original producer and country of production through importation, storage, processing, repackaging, redistribution and retail sale.

2. Traceability continuity during repackaging

Importers, processors and repackagers should be required to preserve the link between original shipment and batch identification and every subsequent package or product lot. Where batches are combined, the records should identify all contributing lots.

3. Traceability during redistribution

Every business receiving or transferring food should maintain records identifying the supplier, recipient, product, quantity, batch and relevant dates. Traceability should not cease when food leaves the importer or repackaging facility.

4. Verification of GAP and GMP compliance

Relevant production and processing records should be maintained and made available for regulatory verification. Importers and repackagers should be able to demonstrate the standards and procedures under which their products were produced and handled.

5. Agricultural chemical disclosure

Relevant pesticide and herbicide application records, including active ingredients and application information, should accompany the food through the supply chain. Consumers should have access to meaningful information about these chemicals and applicable residue compliance.

6. Stronger inspection and testing

Risk-based inspection and appropriate laboratory testing should support the verification of imported food, particularly where the origin, production history, handling or chemical residue profile presents a concern.

7. Verification before distribution

The relevant authorities should have effective procedures to verify required documentation and conduct risk-based inspections or testing before food is authorised for commercial distribution. Where safety or compliance concerns arise, products should be capable of being detained pending appropriate verification.

8. Consumer-accessible traceability information

Food labels should provide meaningful information about origin, producer, importer or repackager and batch identification. QR codes or equivalent digital systems could provide additional information about production practices, relevant chemical use, inspection and testing records.

9. Effective recall and public notification systems

Importers, processors, repackagers and distributors should be able to identify affected products and their destinations promptly. The authorities should have clear procedures for coordinating recalls and informing the public.

Food safety is not simply a matter of compliance. It is a matter of consumer confidence.

Trinidad and Tobago imports a significant proportion of the food consumed locally. Consumers therefore depend on the systems governing the production, inspection, importation, processing and distribution of food beyond our borders, as well as the safeguards operating within our own jurisdiction.

They should not have to assume that a product is safe because it has a local label, a familiar brand or a local distributor.

Nor should businesses that import, process and distribute food be left without clear, consistent requirements governing the records they must maintain and the information they must provide.

A modern food safety framework must be capable of establishing where food originated, how it was produced, whether appropriate agricultural and manufacturing practices were followed, what relevant chemicals were used, whether applicable safety standards were met and where the food has gone.

This is also essential to protecting legitimate businesses. Effective traceability enables responsible operators to demonstrate compliance, supports targeted investigations and reduces the disruption caused by poorly managed recalls.

CAIR is therefore urging the Government to review the implementation and adequacy of existing food traceability arrangements, close regulatory and enforcement gaps, and introduce stronger, enforceable requirements that cover the entire food supply chain, including repackaging and redistribution.

The consumer's right to food safety should not depend on how much information happens to survive the journey from the farm to the supermarket shelf.

From source to shelf, every stage matters. And every stage must be accountable.


Consumer Advocacy and Information Resource (CAIR)

Advocating for informed consumers, safer markets and greater accountability.

References and further reading

  1. Food and Drugs Act, Chap. 30:01 – Trinidad and Tobago, particularly Regulations 16 and 23 of the Food and Drugs Regulations.

  2. National Food Safety Policy 2018–2023 – Government of Trinidad and Tobago.

  3. European Union – Regulation (EC) No. 178/2002, Article 18.

  4. United States FDA – Food Traceability Rule.

  5. United States FDA – Food Traceability Rule Frequently Asked Questions.

Contact CAIR today:


Subscribe to our blog and contact CAIR on any of our pages:

Website: www.cairtt.org
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/cair.tt
Twitter: https://x.com/CAIR1000000
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/cair_1500000/
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@TheConsumerAdvocacy
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/consumer-advocacy-and-information-resource/?viewAsMember=true
Support CAIR:paypal.me/cairtt



 




Blog Archive

From Source to Shelf: Can Consumers Really Know Where Their Food Comes From?

  From Source to Shelf: Can Consumers Really Know Where Their Food Comes From? CAIR examines food traceability, bulk imports, local repackag...